Meghan Markle’s father Thomas ruled fit for trial as doctor claims he was ‘exaggerating’ memory problems
A Florida judge has accepted a psychiatric assessment finding the Duchess of Sussex’s estranged father competent to face prosecution over alleged child sexual abuse material, despite concerns about his health and claims of dementia.
Thomas Markle has been declared mentally competent to stand trial over allegations of possessing child sexual abuse material, after a court-ordered psychiatric assessment found that he could understand the criminal proceedings against him.
The 82-year-old former Hollywood lighting director, who is estranged from his daughter Meghan Markle, the Duchess of Sussex, 45, appeared in federal court in Tampa, Florida, on Thursday (19.11.26.)
His hearing followed Markle’s arrest on 6 November after FBI investigators seized suspected child sexual abuse material from storage units in California.
Markle, who uses a wheelchair following a leg amputation, has denied the allegations and has not entered a formal plea.
According to a medical report considered by the court, psychiatrist Amie Gerodimos concluded: “It is my opinion, with reasonable medical certainty, that Mr Markle is competent to stand trial.”
The assessment was ordered by magistrate judge Lindsay Griffin after Thomas’s lawyers raised concerns about his memory and ability to participate in his defence.
The evaluation took place at Pinellas County Jail on 12 November and examined whether Markle understood the allegations and could assist his legal representatives.
The court heard Markle had significant health problems, including reported memory difficulties, and was receiving treatment for several medical conditions.
However, the psychiatrist concluded his difficulties did not prevent him from understanding the nature of the criminal proceedings.
In her report, Ms Gerodimos said she believed Markle was “exaggerating a lack of recall or understanding of the charges in order to avoid criminal prosecution”.
The doctor noted although Markle initially struggled to recall details of the allegations, he subsequently provided information without prompting and discussed possible approaches to his defence.
She wrote he “consistently described what could be a defence strategy”.
The report also recorded Markle referring to his younger daughter during the interview.
Ms Gerodimos wrote “he pointed out that I might have heard of Meghan”.
Markle’s older daughter Samantha Markle attended the proceedings in support of her father.
According to the assessment, Samantha told the psychiatrist she believed Markle had dementia, although the doctor reached a different conclusion about his ability to face trial.
Markle’s lawyer, Mary Claire Wolf, told the court she would not challenge the psychiatrist’s findings at this stage.
She said: “I reviewed the report with Mr Markle. I suspect he would want to contest it but I do not.”
Markle remains in federal custody following a separate hearing earlier this month, when his release conditions were revoked after authorities accused him of removing his electronic ankle monitor.
He had initially been allowed to remain outside custody following his arrest, subject to electronic monitoring.
Federal prosecutors told the court on 10 November Markle had cut off the device, prompting his return to detention.
The criminal investigation began after allegations emerged concerning material allegedly kept at properties associated with Thomas in the Philippines and the United States.
His son, Thomas Markle Jr, reportedly contacted authorities after discovering suspected child sexual abuse material while clearing out belongings at his father’s former home in the Philippines.
The FBI subsequently searched storage units in the Los Angeles area that investigators said Markle had rented for nearly two decades.
According to federal court filings, agents recovered approximately 78 items, including film negatives, photographic slides and books containing suspected child sexual abuse material.
Investigators alleged some of the images appeared to show Markle with children.
Markle has previously rejected the accusations made by his son, describing them as “sick lies”.
A preliminary court hearing has been scheduled for 1 December, while the criminal proceedings against Markle are expected to involve a possible transfer from Florida to California, where the federal allegations originated.