Matthew Rhys reveals jokes that ruined his James Bond audition before Daniel Craig landed 007 role
The Emmy-winning Welsh actor has recalled an awkward meeting with the Bond producers in London, where an unusual suggestion for the famous spy left the room silent before his career took a very different direction.
Matthew Rhys has revealed how a disastrous joke during his James Bond audition brought his hopes of becoming 007 to an abrupt end – after he suggested the famous secret agent should have a limp and wear an eye patch.
The Welsh actor, 52, who recently enjoyed a remarkable night at the Emmy Awards with two leading actor wins, recalled his unsuccessful attempt to land one of cinema’s most coveted roles during an appearance on Conan O’Brien’s podcast. Matthew was considered for the part in the early 2000s before Daniel Craig, 58, was ultimately chosen to succeed Pierce Brosnan, 73, making his debut in 2006’s Casino Royale.
The audition took place at the Bond producers’ offices overlooking Green Park in London.
Asked by Conan O’Brien, 63, how the meeting had gone, Matthew replied: “Well I’m not playing Bond, nor have I been.”
The actor explained he had visited the offices of the Broccoli family, who had overseen the James Bond franchise for decades, for a meeting about potentially taking over the role.
During the interview, Matthew was asked whether he had read Casino Royale, the novel by Ian Fleming that introduced the British secret agent.
However, the conversation took an unexpected turn when the audition panel asked him to explain how he would approach the character differently.
The panel asked: “So what would you do different with Bond?”
Matthew said: “As a terrible joke, I said, ‘Limp’.”
Rather than changing course, the actor continued with the joke, suggesting his version of Bond should also wear an eye patch.
He recalled: “It went very quiet and then I just fell apart.”
The meeting failed to secure Matthew the role, which eventually went to Daniel, whose interpretation of the British spy began with Casino Royale and continued through four further films.
Daniel went on to star in Quantum of Solace, Skyfall, Spectre and No Time to Die, ending his 15-year tenure as 007 in 2021.
Despite missing out on Bond, Matthew subsequently established himself as a leading television actor, becoming particularly well known for playing Soviet intelligence officer Philip Jennings in the acclaimed spy drama The Americans.
The series, which ran for six seasons, starred Matthew opposite Keri Russell, 50, who played his on-screen wife Elizabeth Jennings. The pair also became partners away from the cameras.
Matthew won an Emmy for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series for his performance in The Americans in 2018.
His other notable credits include playing lawyer Perry Mason in HBO’s period crime drama of the same name, as well as appearances in Brothers and Sisters, A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood and The Post.
Matthew’s career has recently reached another milestone after he made history at the 2026 Emmy Awards, becoming the first performer to win two leading actor prizes for different programmes in the same year.
He won Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series for Widow’s Bay, the Apple TV horror-comedy created by Katie Dippold, 46.
The series follows Mayor Tom Loftis, played by Matthew, as he attempts to transform a mysterious New England island into a tourist destination comparable to Martha’s Vineyard, despite the community’s reputation for supernatural occurrences.
He also received Outstanding Lead Actor in a Limited or Anthology Series or Movie for Netflix’s psychological thriller The Beast in Me, in which he stars opposite Claire Danes, 47.
Matthew plays wealthy property developer Nile Jarvis, a man whose involvement in the disappearance of his first wife becomes central to the mystery.
Claire plays author Aggie Wiggs, who becomes increasingly fascinated by her neighbour while investigating his past.
The two victories also made Matthew the first male performer to win leading actor Emmys across drama, comedy and limited series categories, following his earlier success with The Americans.
His Bond audition has resurfaced amid renewed interest in the franchise following the announcement of Robert Pattinson, 40, as Daniel’s successor.
Robert, best known for playing Edward Cullen in The Twilight Saga and Bruce Wayne in The Batman, is set to take over the role for the next film, which will be directed by Denis Villeneuve, 59.
The franchise is entering a new chapter following Amazon MGM Studios’ assumption of creative control from longtime producers Barbara Broccoli, 66, and Michael G Wilson, 84.