'I didn't want to be the fairy godmother!'

In 2004, Jennifer switched up roles once again as she took on the role of evil stepmother Fiona Montgomery in 'A Cinderella Story' alongside 'Lizzie McGuire' star Hilary Duff and Chad Michael Murray. Despite it being a switch from her 'Legally Blonde' part, she said: "I was so relieved because I thought I'd be the fairy godmother after 'Legally Blonde', I'd been the nice girl. I really never thought I'd be offered something like this."